Whitby MP slams town poll as a 'waste of time and money'

Whitby MP, Robert Goodwill.
Whitby MP, Robert Goodwill.

Whitby’s MP has slammed a move to sever links with Scarborough Council as “a complete waste of time and money”.

More than 40 years of political history could be ripped up if Whitby backs a town poll to ditch Scarborough Council, in favour of the Tees Valley Combined Authority.

The town poll will take place in May.

The town poll will take place in May.


But MP Robert Goodwill says the poll is “a complete distraction”, adding that the move would not be a realistic one.


He said: “There is no local government reorganisation on the cards, it’s a waste of everybody’s time and money.


“My advice to anyone is to not participate.”


Residents will be asked if they want to leave Scarborough to join the Teesside authority in a vote next month which was brought about by members of the public.


At Whitby’s Annual Town Assembly, chaired by the town council, a town poll was proposed by a member of the public asking if a vote could be held to pose the question, which was backed by an overwhelming show of hands.


The town council has confirmed that the poll will now be taking place and has notified the borough council.


A spokesman said: “We have now put the poll to Scarborough Council and they are looking at the legality of the question and they will then come back to us and say ‘yes’ this is a valid question.” The vote will then be held next month at a date yet to be set. But the cost is a bill the town council must foot, which is expected to be several thousand pounds.


Mr Goodwill added that the answer moving forward might be to look at devolving more powers locally to Whitby. He said: “What I would like to see is Whitby Town Council taking over more powers, more town councils are taking on more local powers.

One group which has long been campaigning for action on Scarborough Council’s treatment of the town is Fight4Whitby, member and former town mayor, John Freeman said: “The big part of the problem is that a large section of the population of Whitby is completely disenchanted with treatment from Scarborough over many years and they do not appear to be willing to make any changes.


“Teesside would appear to be a very good option - it’s an area that’s developing and looking forward.


“Whitby would be a massive asset to any area, rather than a drain.”


Many Whitby people remain dissatisfied with the council’s handling of key issues, including the state of the town’s piers, the selling off of the Tourist Information Centre and the town council having to take on many of the public toilets to save them from probable closure.


“I would be very happy to work with them to take on powers from the borough council.” The move to join with the Teesside authority follows an interview by Tees Mayor, Ben Houchen, who suggested that they are looking to expand into North Yorkshire. He told the Local Government Chronicle: “There are vast swathes of North Yorkshire that are much more aligned with the Tees Valley than the rest of Yorkshire…a lot of people who live in North Yorkshire work in Teesside so you could argue there should be an expansion of the Tees Valley deal into North Yorkshire.”


The authority is a partnership of five authorities: Darlington, Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, Redcar & Cleveland and Stockton-on-Tees.


Commenting on the likelihood the poll will vote to leave Scarborough Council and join the Tees Valley, Mr Freeman added: “I think the town is sufficiently dissatisfied to make a move.” The poll is not the first show of discontent.

In February last year, public calls for independence, dubbed ‘Whexit’ came when town councillors backed a motion of ‘no confidence’ in Scarborough Council’s leadership.

Putting forward a proposal, then Cllr Ian Havelock said that he had grown tired of an ethos of “evasion and secrecy”, and called on his fellow councillors to back the motion. They did so, with six votes in favour, four against and two abstentions. Whitby was formerly governed by Whitby Urban and District Council until it was abolished under the Local Government Act of 1972.

The Tees authority offered no comment on the possibility of taking on Whitby, while Scarborough Council also gave no comment to the Gazette on the poll.